England Believes They Played Well in Rome—They're Deluded

There is something peculiar about the water from Roman aqueducts that seems to inspire a slightly hallucinogenic perspective in certain English rugby players. In 2010, Steve Borthwick claimed England had played "fantastic stuff" during a 17-12 win over Italy in Rome. This statement was quickly challenged by teammate Nick Easter, who called the performance "boring," while former captain Lawrence Dallaglio labeled Borthwick's comments "delusional."

lEdpsZAhYRw

Despite the controversy, at least England managed to win, which is more than can be said for Borthwick’s current team. Their style of play bears a striking resemblance to the struggles of the 2010 squad. However, not everyone shares this view. Ben Earl, one of the most consistent performers for England since the World Cup, believed the team delivered an "unbelievable performance" for the first hour of the match against Italy. The only logical response to such a claim is "WTF?"

Earl has earned significant credibility within the team due to his consistent performances. In the Six Nations, he has made a tournament-high 78 carries in four matches—16 more than any other player. His forthrightness is well known. After missing a tackle on South Africa's Damian de Allende, Earl admitted he "probably did not sleep for the two nights, genuinely."

His opinion is always respected, but his take on England's performance at the Stadio Olimpico would be rated high on the Scoville scale. "Firstly, there's an element of pride because I actually thought we played pretty well," Earl said. "I thought we played pretty well for 60 minutes. I can't remember the moment in the game, but there was a moment where I thought only one team was going to win this game."

"Loads went into that game. Can’t fault the preparation, can’t fault the mental attitude of the group. Can’t fault, like, you lose Tom Curry at the warm-up. That could throw a team off, losing a six-Test Lion like that, and the group just adapts and finds ways of thriving in that environment. Like I said, if that game ended at 60 minutes, you’d say that was an unbelievable performance by England. But unfortunately, the result didn’t go our way. Honestly, I am so buoyant with this team; we just have to win some games of rugby and we will."

"The noise around Steve is actually bonkers"

In some ways, this is more concerning than the loss itself. If England's players truly believe they played well in Rome, then it's time to consider a do not resuscitate order. Both Scotland and Ireland raised their intensity significantly, shocking England. As Italy's captain Michele Lamaro noted, the Azzurri were nowhere near their best. Coach Gonzalo Quesada was visibly upset by some of their mistakes. It was probably a 6/10 performance, and they deserved the win.

For the third consecutive game, England struggled at the breakdown, failed to maintain discipline, and performed poorly in the red zone, averaging just 1.5 points per visit to the Italy 22. Yet, according to Earl and others in the England camp, criticism of their performance and the Borthwick regime is "bonkers."

"Just have a think about what this team’s achieved since Steve took over," Earl said. "We’ve gone third in the World Cup. We’ve won 12 out of 15 games, but had won 12 on the bounce. We’ve beaten the All Blacks for the first time in Twickenham since 2012. The noise is actually bonkers, I think it’s crazy because the group, if anyone’s letting Steve down, it’s us."

"I would be fascinated to know if we watch that game back and someone sticks his hand up and goes, tactically that was the wrong decision. I am struggling to think of one now. I can’t think of all the game right now, but there was no decision in the game where I was on the pitch thinking that was the wrong decision tactically. Like I said, 13 v 15 against a team like Italy with some of the runners they have in their backs, it is going to be a tough day. It is going to be a tough last 20 and it was. That’s a lesson."

When asked if he could understand why supporters’ frustration is growing with Borthwick, Earl responded, "No, because what, we’ve lost three on the bounce? England should never lose a game of rugby apparently because of whatever red tape. We have won 12 out of 15 games, if someone asked us 15 games ago you can win 12 of your next 15 games, what do you think you would say?"

There is no issue with Earl's positive outlook, and it's commendable that he addresses the media after the match. However, there is a difference between wearing rose-tinted glasses and having blinkers on. If England genuinely believes they are playing well and just not getting the breaks, they are simply deluded.

A common line used by players and coaches is that they are not the best team in the world after a victory or the worst after a defeat. While this sentiment is noble, if England suffers another loss in Paris on Saturday, Borthwick’s team will be the worst England side in Six Nations history, a title that includes some truly poor performances, including the 2010 team.

Will Greenwood
England's defeat by Italy was a slow-motion train crash
Read more
Sign up to the Front Page newsletter for free: Your essential guide to the day's agenda from The Telegraph - direct to your inbox seven days a week.

Post a Comment for "England Believes They Played Well in Rome—They're Deluded"